A true golden art.
This has long been one of my favourite NG movies. I love most of the things about it.
Graphics - The amount of sprites that would have to be made to do this caught me off-guard when I first watched it. It's a mind-boggling piece of work.
Style - Just good. Many of my favourite parts were in the subtle things, ie: Peanut Butta Jelly banana, Luigi uppercutting Mario into the mushroom box, Mario slicing toads without looking, and such. But I frequently watch this movie just to see the swordfight between Mario and Luigi, I think that's the work of a genius.
Sound - Well done - and don't think I noticed the sounds that were borrowed from RPG Maker. lol
Violence - If I gave it anything less than a 10, it would be an injustice to the movie. :P
Interactivity - It wasn't, but that's not a bad thing. It didn't need it.
Humor - It wasn't supposed to be funny, but I gave it points for my only criticism of the movie, which was the dialogue between Toad, Peach and Luigi on the airship. "I am fine. And you?" That had me laughing. Plus the little subtleties I mentioned earlier.
Overall, an astounding piece of flash wondrousness. Now, WHEN'S THE THIRD MOVIE COMING OUT!?